Interview Prep
The Group Interview Add-on: How to Win When You’re Not Alone
I’m personally not a fan of group interviews, but they do happen.
So what’s DIFFERENT when you’re in a room with 5-10 others all “fighting” for one spot?
How do we think about tackling the call?
Here are a few things to consider…
The #1 rule: it’s a conversation, not a competition
Your goal isn’t to talk the most; it’s to add the most value. The person who wins is the one who listens, engages, and leads the conversation, not the one who just waits for their turn to speak.
The social dynamic: how to stand out
This is the biggest change from a 1-on-1. You’re being judged on how you interact with everyone else.
- Engage With Other Candidates: This is the secret weapon. Use other candidates' names. Nod when they make a good point. Say things like, “That’s a great point, Sarah. To build on that…” This shows you’re a leader and a team player, not just a lone wolf.
- Go First when you have a killer, concise answer to an opening question. It shows confidence.
- Go Middle to build on someone else’s point, showing you can listen and collaborate.
- Go Last to summarize the key points from the group and add your own powerful, final insight. This is a massive power move if you can pull it off.
- Handling Disagreements: If someone says something you disagree with, don’t attack them. Respectfully challenge the idea. “That’s an interesting take, John. In my experience, I’ve found that [alternative approach] actually increased conversions by 20%. Have you ever tried that?” This shows critical thinking without being a jerk.
Nailing the group-specific questions
- The “Who Would You Hire?” Question is common: This is a test of your character and judgment. Don’t dodge it.
- Bad Answer: “Everyone was great.”
- Good Answer: “Based on the conversation, I’d hire Sarah. She mentioned her experience in [specific area] which seems to be a key need, and I was impressed with how she handled the objection question. She seems like a sharp operator.”
- The “Put Your Answer in the Chat” Tactic: Sometimes they’ll ask you to put things like your salary expectations in the chat. This is to see how you anchor yourself without being influenced by others. Be prepared for this and have your number ready.
The follow-up: acknowledging the group
Your follow-up email needs to reflect the group dynamic. Mentioning something specific shows you were paying attention at a higher level.
Example Snippet:
“I really enjoyed the discussion today. It was interesting to hear Sarah’s perspective on [topic], and it confirmed for me that my experience in [your experience] would be a huge asset in solving that problem.”
This is by NO means, comprehensive. Every group interview is different so the goal is to not “overcoach you” to the point you turn into a robotic, rehearsed, automaton. This is simply to get your wheels turning. If you have other helpful tips and tricks that you think others could benefit from please let me know if they should be added!