Compensation Guide

How to Structure a Comp Plan

A rep should be able to understand how they get paid. Start with the earning event, payout timing, and what happens when a deal refunds. Then check whether the math works for both sides.

10 min read Updated October 21, 2026 By Zach Brown

The Three Models (And When to Use Each)

Here are three structures to consider. The rates below are examples for planning, not measured market norms or a recipe that guarantees retention.

Model 1: Commission-Only

The rep earns a percentage of every deal they close. No base salary, no draw. They eat what they kill.

What can support it:

  • • Enough qualified shown calls to support the earnings estimate
  • • Conversion evidence from your actual offer
  • • Ticket size and commission that fit the workload
  • • You want to attract experienced closers

What to check:

  • • Inconsistent or low lead volume
  • • New offer with unproven conversion
  • • A sales cycle that delays income beyond what the rep can afford
  • • You want to attract junior talent to train

Example: A closer could earn 10% of cash collected. Setter pay can include a base, qualified-show pay, a share of collected sales, or a combination. Define attribution and model earnings from the actual workload.

Model 2: Base + Commission

A fixed base plus commission shares some income risk with the company. The right amount depends on the scope, ramp, and business economics.

What can support it:

  • • You're building a team (not just one closer)
  • • Longer ramp-up period expected
  • • The role needs dependable coverage during a ramp
  • • You can afford the fixed cost

What to check:

  • • Cash-tight businesses that can't absorb fixed costs
  • • Whether the agreed work and support are actually happening
  • • When you set the base too high relative to commission

Example: $3,000 base plus 10% of cash collected. At $75,000 collected in a month, that pays $10,500 total. That is scenario math, not a universal OTE target or a retention guarantee.

Model 3: Draw Against Commission

You advance the rep a guaranteed amount each pay period, which they "pay back" from their commissions. If they earn more than the draw, they keep the excess. If they earn less, they owe the difference (recoverable) or you eat it (non-recoverable).

What can support it:

  • • A defined ramp based on the sales cycle and available work
  • • You believe in the rep but need time to prove lead flow
  • • Transitional structure before going full commission

What to check:

  • • Unclear review dates or what happens after the draw ends
  • • Recoverable draws that create debt = resentment
  • • If commission stays below the draw, check lead flow, ramp, and performance before assigning blame

Recommendation: Set the amount, duration, review date, and what happens next before starting. A ramp should fit the work, not an arbitrary 30-day rule. Be explicit about recoverability.

The Clawback Question

Clawbacks are the single most contentious topic in high-ticket comp plans. Here's the deal:

A clawback means if a client refunds or cancels within a certain window, the rep's commission on that deal is taken back. The logic is sound — you shouldn't pay commission on revenue you didn't keep.

But here's where it goes wrong:

Timing doesn't establish fault. A refund on day 87 doesn't tell you whether the problem was selling, fulfillment, or something else. I don't have evidence for a universal industry-standard clawback window.

Clawbacks on payment plans are tricky. If you pay commission on the full deal value upfront but the client stops paying at month 3 of 6 — who eats that? Define this in writing BEFORE it happens.

Check the cause: A refund percentage alone doesn't identify a fulfillment problem. Review what was promised, what was delivered, and what happened before assigning blame.

What the Historical Report Says

My March 3, 2026 report analyzed 273 companies using records from 2023–2026. Its earnings sections are labeled monthly commission. These are reported sample figures, not a current industry pay scale:

RoleData pointsMedianReported 25th / 75th percentiles
Setter108$5,000/monthNot reported
Closer304$11,000/month$8,000 / $14,000

The report does not establish verified base-plus-commission totals or a manager pay distribution. Use it as historical context, then model the actual earning opportunity for your role.

The Comp Plan Checklist

Before you publish your comp plan, make sure it passes these tests:

  • Can you explain it in 2 sentences? If not, simplify it. Complexity breeds distrust.
  • Can the rep calculate their own earnings? They should be able to look at their pipeline and know exactly what they'll make.
  • Is the OTE realistic given your lead flow? Show every input. For example: 8 shown calls/week × 4 weeks × 20% close rate × $5,000 fully collected × 10% commission = $3,200 before any base. Change the inputs and the answer changes.
  • Is it in writing? Not a Slack message. A document. Signed by both parties.
  • Are clawback terms defined? Window length, what triggers them, how they're calculated.
  • Is there a path to earn more? Tiers, bonuses, or accelerators for top performance.
  • When does it get paid? Weekly? Bi-weekly? On cash collected or on close? Define it.

Common Mistakes

Changing the comp plan without notice. Nothing destroys trust faster. If you need to change it, give 30 days notice and grandfather existing deals.

Paying on "cash collected" but not defining what that means. Does it include payment plan installments? Upsells? Renewals? Define every term.

Setting commission too low to attract talent. Five percent of a fully collected $3,000 sale is $150. What does that produce with your actual volume, any base, and the work required? One percentage can't tell you whether someone should accept the role.

Making it too complex. Tiered structures with 5 levels, different rates for different products, bonuses that require a spreadsheet to calculate — all of this creates confusion and distrust.

Need Help Structuring Your Comp Plan?

I review comp plans on every staffing game plan call. If your structure is off, I'll tell you — and help you fix it before you hire. Free, no obligation.